Winter Maintenance – Case Study


![]()
Background
The Property Management team at Bannon currently manage over 70 commercial sites across Ireland. The portfolio is made up of Shopping Centres, Retail Parks, Business Parks and Office Parks.
In recent years there has been an unquestionable shift in weather patterns, and this is particularly noticeable in the colder winter months. One such example was the severe weather experienced in February 2018 when Storm Emma hit Ireland. During the course of the storm, we saw significant accumulations of snow across our sites and temperatures as low as –11.0°C.
In any given year we see c.100 million visits to Bannon managed sites across the country and maintaining safe access to these sites is a crucial part of our role as Property Managers. We manage this risk by appointing contractors to carry out gritting services during periods of cold weather and snow clearance when required.
A number of years ago we recognised the obvious synergies associated with managing our winter maintenance services on a portfolio basis. For that reason, we have split our portfolio into three distinct zones (see below) and we tender the contract every 3 years.
Zone 1 – Greater Dublin Area
Zone 2 – South & South East
Zone 3 – Midlands, West & North West
Tender
A sub-team of Property Managers were appointed to oversee the tendering of the Winter Maintenance contract for the portfolio. The following tender process occurred;
Phase 1 – Review of portfolio geography and creation of 3 distinct zones
Phase 2 – Preparation of Request for Tender (RFT) document
Phase 3 – Shortlisting of suitable contractors including a visit to contractors’ facilities
Phase 4 – Issue RFT to shortlisted parties
Phase 5 – Review & analysis of tenders
Phase 6 – Selection & contract award to winning tenderers
In total the RFT was issued to 10 contractors and we received 6 complete tender submissions. The submissions were assessed and ranked based on pre-set criteria. All but one tenderer submitted a proposal for all three zones. The sub-team assessed the proposals and made a recommendation to the directors of the department to appoint three separate contractors (one per zone). This recommendation was followed and the contracts were awarded to the following parties;
Zone 1 – Greater Dublin Area – SAP Landscapes
Zone 2 – South & South East – O’Brien Facilities
Zone 3 – Midlands, West & North West – Ken Fitzsimons Landscaping
Benefits
The benefits of carrying out a procurement process of this nature are far reaching, to include;
- Value – The buying power of procuring the same service across 70 sites at the same time.
- Service – The inclusion of strict KPI’s in the respective contracts means a consistent approach across the portfolio.
- Health & Safety – Once predicted weather conditions meet a certain pre-agreed criteria our contractors will automatically mobilise to all sites and carry out gritting. In so far as is possible we have attempted to remove any subjectivity from the decision-making process.
- Insurance – Each appointed contractor has undergone an extensive vetting process to include a detailed review of their insurances.
- Administration – The associated burden of managing individual contractors across 70 sites has been significantly reduced.
Overall, we have seen significant benefits in procuring our Winter Maintenance services on a portfolio wide basis. Our retail clients can enjoy consistency of service across all sites. With a proactive and data driven approach, we ensure that footfall does not drop and visitor health and safety is managed.














The function of all forms of real estate and the specific requirements of its users continues to change at pace. The most significant factors driving this evolution are non-financial – Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) requirements.







culture of the market and understand the importance of real estate delivering long term returns for our clients. However, we believe this can be done in a way that simultaneously creates better places to work and reduces the impact on the environment.














Dublin Town reporting footfall in the City Centre at 87% of 2019 levels last Saturday, given the lack of Tourists that’s a very encouraging recovery. It will be interesting to see which retailers benefit most from the return of the consumer.
Following the government’s transposition of IORP II, any new One Member Arrangements (OMA) will now be largely prevented from borrowing for their investments and be required to hold at least 50% of their investment in regulated markets e.g. listed shared and/or bonds.




After the pandemic: in Dublin’s bare city. Our streets must be reimagined to entice visitors rather than cater to workers. Bannon advises on this in 
















Last minute residential deal tips market over €3bn.




In general the footfall across our portfolio is remarkably consistent every year, however 2020 is very different. We remain hopeful that people will shop with purpose when the restrictions are eased at the start of December.
The inconsistent and illogical nature of the imposition of essential goods only sales in retail across the country is causing serious damage to the sector.















