Winter Maintenance – Case Study


![]()
Background
The Property Management team at Bannon currently manage over 70 commercial sites across Ireland. The portfolio is made up of Shopping Centres, Retail Parks, Business Parks and Office Parks.
In recent years there has been an unquestionable shift in weather patterns, and this is particularly noticeable in the colder winter months. One such example was the severe weather experienced in February 2018 when Storm Emma hit Ireland. During the course of the storm, we saw significant accumulations of snow across our sites and temperatures as low as –11.0°C.
In any given year we see c.100 million visits to Bannon managed sites across the country and maintaining safe access to these sites is a crucial part of our role as Property Managers. We manage this risk by appointing contractors to carry out gritting services during periods of cold weather and snow clearance when required.
A number of years ago we recognised the obvious synergies associated with managing our winter maintenance services on a portfolio basis. For that reason, we have split our portfolio into three distinct zones (see below) and we tender the contract every 3 years.
Zone 1 – Greater Dublin Area
Zone 2 – South & South East
Zone 3 – Midlands, West & North West
Tender
A sub-team of Property Managers were appointed to oversee the tendering of the Winter Maintenance contract for the portfolio. The following tender process occurred;
Phase 1 – Review of portfolio geography and creation of 3 distinct zones
Phase 2 – Preparation of Request for Tender (RFT) document
Phase 3 – Shortlisting of suitable contractors including a visit to contractors’ facilities
Phase 4 – Issue RFT to shortlisted parties
Phase 5 – Review & analysis of tenders
Phase 6 – Selection & contract award to winning tenderers
In total the RFT was issued to 10 contractors and we received 6 complete tender submissions. The submissions were assessed and ranked based on pre-set criteria. All but one tenderer submitted a proposal for all three zones. The sub-team assessed the proposals and made a recommendation to the directors of the department to appoint three separate contractors (one per zone). This recommendation was followed and the contracts were awarded to the following parties;
Zone 1 – Greater Dublin Area – SAP Landscapes
Zone 2 – South & South East – O’Brien Facilities
Zone 3 – Midlands, West & North West – Ken Fitzsimons Landscaping
Benefits
The benefits of carrying out a procurement process of this nature are far reaching, to include;
- Value – The buying power of procuring the same service across 70 sites at the same time.
- Service – The inclusion of strict KPI’s in the respective contracts means a consistent approach across the portfolio.
- Health & Safety – Once predicted weather conditions meet a certain pre-agreed criteria our contractors will automatically mobilise to all sites and carry out gritting. In so far as is possible we have attempted to remove any subjectivity from the decision-making process.
- Insurance – Each appointed contractor has undergone an extensive vetting process to include a detailed review of their insurances.
- Administration – The associated burden of managing individual contractors across 70 sites has been significantly reduced.
Overall, we have seen significant benefits in procuring our Winter Maintenance services on a portfolio wide basis. Our retail clients can enjoy consistency of service across all sites. With a proactive and data driven approach, we ensure that footfall does not drop and visitor health and safety is managed.






























Dublin Town reporting footfall in the City Centre at 87% of 2019 levels last Saturday, given the lack of Tourists that’s a very encouraging recovery. It will be interesting to see which retailers benefit most from the return of the consumer.




After the pandemic: in Dublin’s bare city. Our streets must be reimagined to entice visitors rather than cater to workers. Bannon advises on this in 




Despite the challenges facing the north-east this year due to impending Brexit and stricter lockdowns than their counterparts on either side of the border, it’s great to have some positive news and see Harry Corry open their latest store in Cavan Retail Park. Harry Corry are an international retailer specialising in home furnishings and this letting brings the park to full occupancy, further re-affirming the resilience of the retail park market.




Bannon are delighted to welcome Bag City to Marshes Shopping Centre, Dundalk in the lead up to Christmas despite a turbulent 2020. Jennifer Mulholland, Divisional Director, comments that the addition of Bag City to the Tenant mix at Marshes is another positive testament for the scheme which continues to be the North East’s most dominant retail scheme.
Great to welcome Name It to The Square Town Centre, Tallaght! Fantastic news to start off the Christmas season.
As we exit level 5 restrictions, there is cause for double celebrations yesterday in Swords Pavilions Shopping Centre with the opening of 2 new stores. Great to see both Golden Discs & Catch open their doors in the lead up to Christmas.
We are delighted to be part of the team to deliver the new Aldi store in Blanchardstown. This will be a fantastic addition to the scheme which continues to grow and improve with new tenants and mall improvements.
Great to see local menswear brand Walker & Hunt going from strength to strength and gradually making the shift from online to bricks and mortar, taking space in Athlone Town Centre for the second year in a row, opening soon.
In general the footfall across our portfolio is remarkably consistent every year, however 2020 is very different. We remain hopeful that people will shop with purpose when the restrictions are eased at the start of December.
Bannon are delighted to welcome Eden Medical Clinic to MacDonagh Junction Shopping Centre, Kilkenny. Great to be involved in securing new store openings despite current level 5 restrictions.

The inconsistent and illogical nature of the imposition of essential goods only sales in retail across the country is causing serious damage to the sector.






Liverpool FC have launched a brand new pop-up store in the Swords Pavilions Shopping Centre, making it the second official club store in Dublin.









Specsavers have now joined the tenant line up in Manor Mills Shopping Centre. The store is equipped with the latest eye and ear testing technology. Maynooth is the only Specsavers store in North Kildare.
Harvey Norman is to open its new store in Knocknacarra in April with the creation of over 60 jobs.
The first drive-thru Starbucks on Ireland’s east coast has opened at Marshes Shopping Centre and coffee lovers should keep an eye out for promotions throughout the week.



